What Would You Do?

Hypothetically speaking, what would you do if..oh, lets say..you were making pecan pies for Thanksgiving dinner, and you looked over to find that one of your cats had jumped up on the counter, and was sniffing one of your pie shells. (hypothetically speaking, of course) lol

Would you.....
a. run to the store for new pie shells.
b. use them, and just don't tell anyone.
c. use them, and wait until everyone has had a piece before telling them.

Hypothetically of course. lol