Shrub recommendation

Eau Claire, WI(Zone 4a)

Some time ago I posted about a White Pine I've got that suffered two consecutive years where wet, heavy snow stripped off several branches. This tree is recovering nicely, but I'd like to smooth out the lower roughness by screening the trunk. My initial thought was to plant a slow growing conifer, but it has been brought to my attention that this might not be the most effective means. I'm now considering a large shrub to accomplish this.

The site is shady, getting less than four hours of sun. It's well-watered and will be mulched as part of a bed that will tie-in the pine, small Japanese x Korean maple, and the shrub to be planted. Any suggestions?

Thumbnail by Pseudo
(Robin) Blissfield, MI(Zone 6a)

Aesculus parviflora var. serotina
Aesculus pavia
Amelanchier x grandiflora 'Princess Diana'
Those aren't even all the A's here
http://www.lazyssfarm.com/Plants/Shrubs/A-Ch%20Shrubs/shrubs_trees_A-B.htm
You have so many good choices...don't forget the never disappointing Viburnums...

Lake Stevens, WA(Zone 8a)

I kind of like the lawn-with-trees look you have now. Are you looking for a tall fat shrub? or short? It might look kind of lonely all by itself, as you have no other shrubs there.
How about Daphne mezereum, that should survive in the frosty north, in a woodland? Pretty fragrant early spring flowers, then berries for the birds. Sort of boring to look at in summer, but you have lots of other stuff for then!

Eau Claire, WI(Zone 4a)

Actually, I'm not sure what I'm looking for, but a bushy-like(?) shrub that is choice, shade tolerant, and deer resistant would be ideal. A shrub of 10'-15' would be just right. Beautiful flowers and fruit coveted by critters would make me sing with delight. Finally, a plant with four seasons of interest would be out of sight.

Saint Louis, MO(Zone 6a)

Not having the lyrical gift, I won't try to mimic the rhyming cadence, nice as it was. Mipii started you off through the A-options (strangely omitting Aronia or even those cold-hardy 'Lights'-series Azaleas), before she tired and veered recklessly toward the V-option. They all still sound like good choices, even the V's.

Lexington, MA(Zone 6a)

Personally, I am starting to appreciate azaleas, natives especially, but not exclusively, to use for underplantings. Not the little bright ball- shaped things you see, but a naturalistic planting of different sizes, colors and bloom times. If you look for books or postings about Winterthur, you'll see what I mean.

You'll have fun looking at all the possibilities. The scheme around my own pine trees includes plants of all heights. Closer to the ground level are the aronia and viburnums, hollies-- deciduous has winter interest too, also ilex glabra, dwarf witch hazel, rhodis and flame azalea, aronia, enkianthus, snowberry, sambucus, myrica, yes to a section with miniature conifers and slightly larger Gentsch white hemlock (adelgid resistant). For red winter color there are service dogwoods including "Pucker up," the arctic series, and Kelseyii, of which, so far I think I may just keep Pucker up (TM). It is a work in progress with a large section of it still an earthworks surrounded by plants in pots. Slightly taller (in theory) are the florida dogwood, a clump of canadian amalanchier and a pair of ilex pedunculosa, and a bit to the side is the cornus mas.

I learned that some of the asian azalea hybrids growing about a foot high are tolerant to zone 5, but I will not test that away from the house until a few more are mature.

Saint Louis, MO(Zone 6a)

Sounds awfully nice. I expect the 'work in progress' will be a continuously apt descriptor.

(Robin) Blissfield, MI(Zone 6a)

Lol Wee. I just started listing everything in zone 4 that I wanted. If I hadn't strategically veered to the V's, I would have been there all day.

And, if I had my way I'd have everything Rosemary has too...

sounds great Rosemary! I'd like some photo proof but, I'm not going to ask you for it and put you on the spot, haha.

Eau Claire, WI(Zone 4a)

Thanks to all for the ideas. I wish you could come here for a garden party. Oh, don't forget to bring your designs and plants. :)

Rosemary, I've been thinking about rhododendrons/azaleas for this site. There's also a large oak about 20' from the pine, which I could underplant with azaleas and tie it together. Do azaleas need more sun than rhododendrons? Anyhow, this is going to require a lot more time and thought. I will keep you posted, but if I do azaleas it is going to take considerable effort to prepare the site. I spent most of today refreshing a border with mulch. Planting is more fun...

Lexington, MA(Zone 6a)

This is fun! It probably has to be avirtual garden party, though.

Oak and pine make some very useful tree litter. It's dark so I can't go out and take a pic now, but I will sometime later. My area is pretty shady but I periodically have the trees thinned. The fun part is looking for where the breaks are in the shade. The other part of the fun is finding those shrubs that are more shade tolerant.

Even tougher than that is protecting them from the little animals that love to eat them. The azaleas are getting wire mesh cages so the new ones can be planted and the older ones can grow past the haircut. Once they are fully established I don't think they will mind as much.

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.
BACK TO TOP