debating pond liners

Oak Grove, MN(Zone 4a)

Hi everyone,

When I lived in Michigan, I had a 700 gallon pond built from 3 preforms run together. I left the pond, fish, everything behind when we moved to Minnesota 2 years ago.

Now a neighbor and I are going to build a new pond in his yard. We want to go much larger and use a liner, but I've never done liners and he's never done ponds.

What is everyone's experience with liners? I hear that rubber roof liner is safe for fish and much cheaper than "pond" liner - is this true?

Would really appreciate some help!

Thank you!

Sylvi

springfield area, MO(Zone 5b)

I priced rubber roof liner and it was not any cheaper.
Yes it is safe for ponds, fish ect, I have a couple friends who have large ponds with it.
I bought a liner on Ebay.
I think it was a 60 mil. It is very thick whatever it was, and I was pleased with it.

Milford, CT(Zone 6a)

I have a 1200 gallon pond, prefab upper wuit a waterfall into the 900 gallon lower liner pond.. been running 3 years.. I found the pond liner better to customize with plant ledges, and deeper so I leave fish out all winter. I used 2 cheap tarps under to cushin and 3 pieces of a 25 foot wide roll of 20 mil black plastic.. I think it all came in around 200 bucks with the pump-pond kit for the waterfall... the 60 mil sold at the pond stores looked perfect but the size i wanted would have been 200 bucks or so if i remember right before everything else .. I never had a problem with the layered 20 mil just bought a whole roll and layed it in till I ran out - no regrets the pond is beautiful...
-joe-

Milford, CT(Zone 6a)

I really need to spell check.........

springfield area, MO(Zone 5b)

regular black plastic will work, except it won't last for long because it is not UV resistant and the sun will break it down in a few years.
The pond liner have 15 or 20 yr warranties. You should still use carpet, sand ect even with a pond liner though, so rocks won't damage it.

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.
BACK TO TOP