Thoughts on Golden Foliage Plumeria?

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

We're being offered a new (to us at least) Plumeria out of Thailand. We've been expanding our line of them, but I'm not so sure if this one should be added. It's called Plumeria rubra aurea, and has yellow gold foliage. While I'm a huge fan of the variegated ones coming out of there, I'm not sold on this one and thought I'd see what the Plumeria fans thought of it.

I don't have any info on flower color or scent yet,. It would also be pricey, in the $70-$85 as a rooted plant. Lower price would be for single tips, and graduate up for more tips. I bought a Maya for my self from Brads, and that was about $80, and I felt it was worth it for something so unique.

Thoughts?

Thanks,

Chris

Thumbnail by BuriedTreasures
Pittsburg, MO(Zone 6b)

Don't know much about Plummies but that sure is pretty. It has a beautiful glow to it. But me, myself, I wouldn't buy it because I would look at it and think it was dying all the time with the yellow like leaves. But then again if it had a flower to look at I could then remember it is supposed to look that way.

Millsap, TX

The foilage is Beautiful...Not sure I would pay the price tho.. I would love see the bloom ..LOL Might just make me change my mind...
Kylie

La Grange, TX(Zone 8b)

I like the variegated foliaged ones. This one looks chlorotic. Do you know whether that color has any effect on its growth rate? Pricey and no details on flower color and fragrance. I don't think I'd buy it.

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

Not a clue on anything other than what I offered. I can probably find out the flower color, but they don't tend to focus on fragrance in Thailand.

The minimum is very low, so I only have to try 30. I'll grow a few out to get and idea. I just wasn't sure if there would be any appeal to the foliage. So far the opinions have been split.

Chris

Montgomery, TX(Zone 9a)

I would buy a tip or two for the coloring alone, very nice.

Vero Beach, FL

were is Valrico ? i'm in vero beach. it looks very interesting,i hope you keep us all informed on it's progress.

Tampa, FL(Zone 10a)

I find the foilage to be very attractive and 'gold' leaves are popular at this moment. Would be nice in a mixed planting. I think it might need darker foilage behind it to make it more noticeable in a landscape.

I would buy one, but, it would have to be good sized for $80. Plumeria is an expensive plant, generally, so I shy away from them.

Thumbnail by DaleTheGardener

I would not go for this. There are many dodgy plants coming out of Thailand and I am very careful who I buy from over there.

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

I agree, however, this is the same source that BT has been purchasing from for 6 years, and my Father's company for 10. The concern isn't with the company, but the desirability of a Plumeria with yellow foliage by design. Heck, I can create that on my own through neglect. :-)

Not to say they're perfect, as standards for consistancy are very loose in Thailand. The way we promote them usually doesn't leave room for dissapointment, and now and then creates some unexpected surprises. It turned out that the "Rainbow Shades" we offered this year, were actually Neville's Rainbow. Not a bad $8.95 surprise. then one of our alocasias that Laraanne ordered, ended up in an exciting article as something pretty special.

I'll bring in the minimum of 30, and see how it goes.

Chris

Tampa, FL(Zone 10a)

Chris,

Is Neville's Rainbow a plumeria? And a little more info on the alocasia surprise, maybe a reference to the article also?

not a plumeria>

Thumbnail by DaleTheGardener

I have never heard of Neville's Rainbow - it may be a mis-spelling of Nebel's Rainbow, and they are good at 'guessing' at the spelling of names in Thailand.
My favorite is the variety 'Mango Blush' which comes from Thailand as 'Mango Brush'.
LOL

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

Here's the Article LariAnn wrote on what we receive as Alocasia Maechang.

That's not exactly a misspelling on Mango Blush, but more of a phonetics issue. Asians typically pronounce "L" as "R", so when one is telling an English speaking person the name Mango Blush, it's naturally spelled Mango Brush by the English speaking as that's how it's pronounced. You should see some of the emails floating around with signs from the Beijing Ollympics, with their English translations. They're a hoot.

It happens as much on this side of the pond as well, The Rainbow was identified to me by a breeder in Texas with an Oklahoma drawl. Over the phone, it sounded like Neville's Rainbow. :-) He told me what it was, and said I needed to raise my prices.

East Texas, United States(Zone 8a)

Chris, where is article on mae chang?

I am definitely intrigued by this thread. I love to be the first on my block to get this unsual plant or another, but something here is not jellying. First of all nomenclature. It's only adjectives and contradictory at best. Rubra is red, aurea is yellow flower. So it is red or is it yellow? What makes for the yellow foliage? I hate to admit it but it looks sickly to me. Then again, we must remember this is the #1 detractor of golden foliage: if located incorrectly in the garden scheme, it just looks sick, lol. no two ways about it. And I'm not a golden hater, in fact I adore golden foliage.

Like Hetty, I am generally suspicious of thai vendors but you are a big boy and your business acumen should guide you. And I'm glad not everybody is suspicious. Thank goodness for those that will take a leap of faith. Otherwise, we would all still believe the world is flat.

Tampa, FL(Zone 10a)

You mean the world is not flat??

brom flower>

Thumbnail by DaleTheGardener
Tampa, FL(Zone 10a)

You mean the world is not flat?? But, it looks so flat....

brom flower>

Thumbnail by DaleTheGardener
Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

Shoot. The link must have fallen off when I hit send. ;-)

http://davesgarden.com/guides/articles/view/1401/

I do have some on order for January, but as of Friday, they're still trying to find some more.

While it's true to be wary of people you've never done business with, I think it's completely undeserving to say be wary of Thai vendors as a whole. I've dealt with as many if not more, dishonest people here in Florida, the USA, The Netherlands, Germany and the rest of the world. Having stayed with these people for several weeks, and having hosted them here at my home, I can say I couldn't ask for better people to work with.

What is definitely a Thai trait, is lack of concern for detail. Mai pin rai is very common phrase when errors occur. Roughly translated it means, It's ok. Life goes on. To be wary of Thai vendors, is a bit much though. They'll generally bend over backward to make sure you are pleased.

Sawas dee krup.

Chris

Just to reiterate: I said:

Quoting:
There are many dodgy plants coming out of Thailand and I am very careful who I buy from over there.

I do believe if you stayed with these people you clearly have a long standing relationship and need to have no worries about their integrity.

I maintain the point that many dodgy plants have come out of Thailand in recent years. Which is why I only buy from sellers there who have come recommended by trusted sources.

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

There are as many "dodgy" plants coming out of Miami, India, Israel, and Europe as well.

Miami alone has a huge issue with unlicensed propagation of patented material, while places like India and Israel are notorious for ignoring US patents, importing plants through back channels, and reproducing them en mass under a different name.

It's important to know your source, regardless of their location or nationality.

Chris

Mulberry, FL

This day and time its all about the price and the thailand people have dropped it like a stone.

Tucson, AZ

looks like a plumie going dormant. LOL

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

My thoughts as well. Hopefully it will look better in person and grown out. Might be something for local sales only, if I can't get a good pic that represents it.

Chris

Tucson, AZ

i always think about photosynthesis when i see these variegated plumeria...

Montgomery, TX(Zone 9a)

I like the gold coloring, very vibrant. Not like the color of one going dormant to me.

North of Atlanta, GA(Zone 8a)

It is a beautiful plant. I think most Plumeria collectors would be interested in buying it. If I lived in the right climate where I can grow the Plumeria outside and would see blooms, I would heavily consider it.

I've done lots of business with Vietnam and they are just like what you said above - laid back. I wouldn't want to hijack your thread and would be glad to discuss it with anyone through dmail. I just find that the labor may be cheap over there but you don't always get quality. I am willing to pay a little more for them to get it right the first or second time. I want to be able to stand behind my product when I'm advertising it. Here in the US, your name and reputation is everything to make your business successful and they don't see it that way.

Plumiedelphia, PA(Zone 7a)

If the gold is its true color keep it in partial shade
Full sun will either burn it or make it go green.
I have 2 yellows (golds) and 1 peach color
I also have 1 that is chloritic by nature.
Supplements wont cure it so it stays mottled.
Good Luck Chris
I like it but am not in the plumie buying market as I have my fill lol!

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

Thanks Malestrom.

We roll the dice on a few plants each year. It's no biggie with a minimum of 30. There are other plants that have a minimum that range from 250 to 5000. We have to think those through pretty closely.

We're still struggling with Heliconia, but are going to give it a final shot this season, hoping the new greenhouse will give us the additional heat needed.

Chris

East Texas, United States(Zone 8a)

malestrom, do you have pics of your yellows? and do you mean var. yellow or completely yellow?

Chris I'm w/ you about heliconias. Can't keep them alive. I think I will start a thread about them. I suspect I'm overwatering

Plumiedelphia, PA(Zone 7a)

Vos, they are completely gold upon formation of new leafs.
They slowly gain a green hue but remain 'gold'
I do have pics.
http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v515/Malestrom22/My%20Plumies/Oddities/?action=view¤t=GoldLeaf2.jpg

East Texas, United States(Zone 8a)

OMG I am totally in love and lust. Also feel like I've been living under a rock since I haven't seen anything like it, til your pic. what color flower?

Citra, FL

deleted

This message was edited Dec 17, 2008 11:05 PM

Montgomery, TX(Zone 9a)

LOL@!

Plumiedelphia, PA(Zone 7a)

hasnt bloomed yet ;)
Ill be sure to post when she does
I have peach leaf and black too ;)

Vos, Ill keep you in mind when she grows a tad more.
You and I have traded b-4 no?

This message was edited Dec 21, 2008 5:38 AM

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

Oooooh. Black Leaf???????? I'm certain you can find something in our meager offerings that you may like to trade a cutting of that for when it reaches a suitable size.

:-)

Plumiedelphia, PA(Zone 7a)

Chris, youre never short on what i want lol!
Ill keep you 1st in line ;)

Geneva, FL(Zone 9b)

Chris,

I would like to chime in and share some of my experiencees with Thailand. I have been buying plumerias from Thailand for a few years now and it took me a while to develop HONEST and reliable sources. The fact that you have found just that means you are very fortunate. However, I have to say that while there are indeed good Thai sellers, there are also just as many dishonest ones that would sell you a commmon white labeled as 'Dane" or another expensive hybrid without a second thought. Yes there are dishonest people in the whole world, BUT, the rest of the world is not the center of the plumeria trade at the moment. Thailand is; with more new cvs coming out of it than anywhere else.

Having been burned myself by what one friend of mine living in Thailand calls the "Chatuchak Surprise" (plants purchased at the market by fly-by-night sellers that later bloomed as common white), and, after working extra hard to find my reliable sources, I can say first hand it is not a direct insult to the Thai people as a whole, who are generally very sweet people, but, rather a word of caution for all people just starting out in importation of plants-- that there are many dishonest and fly-by-night sellers over there who are making lots of money of foreign trade through venues like Ebay.

There was BIG money in plumeria for a couple of years, and, as a result, many unscrupulous sellers magically appeared overnight, claiming to have nurseries, when in fact, they did not. They purchased plants here and there from the markets from other fly-by-night sellers and many people got screwed---really so.The demand was so hot two years ago that the temptation was a big one for anyone wishing to make fast money.

One friend of mine who lives in Bangkok and who is not Thai, says that he is daily amused at the carelessness and outright cut-throat dealings of the average Thai plant sellers (who are not the big players). He has been living there for 15 years and can tell you a lot about the local market in the Bangkok area. Some Thais have gone as far as to bribe officials to help shut down their competition through "violations", have bribed export brokerages and shippers to not deal with the competition. Others who are more established yet still keep a booth at local markets, simply will keep dropping their prices to ridiculous lows just so the plumeria booth next to them at the market can no longer afford to sell and goes out of business.

One seller I know in Chiang Mai got his entire field of plumerias and other tropicals set on fire and burned to the ground. The neighbors all knew who it was but were afraid to tell him, saying they believed the man's bad karma would come upon them if they got involved and gave any information to help in the investigation. The man was never caught and my friend lost a lot of money as well as his dreams.

Once again, there are some wonderful Thai people, many of whom I am happy to know and to do business with; some I call friends. However, the demand for Thai cultivars has indeed brought out a lot of bad people who only care to cash in now and then simply disappear later.

Another note--a good Thai friend of mine warned me that many of the plants being purchased by the plant sellers on Ebay--,most of which are picked up at the local markets, are infected with a host of viruses and disease. These plants pose a menace to collectors here in the USA if their collection plants were to be exposed to them. Many of the market sellers are either ignorant of plant diseases, or, simply do not care. This is why it is so important for American buyers to know from whom they are really getting their plants. For the average buyer with a small collection it is probably better and safer to deal with an American seller of Thai varieties who is established with good connections for healthy plants from Thailand.

It will be interesting though to note what happens this coming year with the bad economy as well as a major saturation of the market with a dizzying supply of plumeria varieties. Values for imported plants started falling this past summer and God only knows what will happen this next season. I suspect there will be fewer of the Thai EBay sellers as the BIG FAST money of the "Plumeria Bubble" is now a memory and many will move on to new ventures. The days of new plants selling for well over $100 is, on a large scale, over. Hopefully this will thin out the market to a sane and rational condition with the committed, tried and true sellers sticking around. Even though prices are going to continue to fall, at least those that remain in the business will be fewer and trustworthy, whether Thai, Israeli, German, American, or whatever.

By the way, I haven't seen your golden leafed variety yet. It is quite pretty.
You do indeed offer some nice plants, Chris, as well as excellent customer service. I am glad to see you are among those sticking around in the business.

Happy New Year to you and to everyone else on Daves!

Brad

Plumiedelphia, PA(Zone 7a)

Dittos on Brads insights.
I stick to only a few sellers whom I know well enough to trust with my $$
Brad is high on the list
It seems Suki has disappeared dangit
She was awesome.
I buy often enough from you Chris that you should know you have my confidence ;)
All COT doing well for our single digit winters
5 degrees tonight 45 mph winds brrr...

East Texas, United States(Zone 8a)

2nd ditto on Brad's insights. Like, wow, well said!

Valrico, FL(Zone 9b)

Brad,

It's your fault that I have these coming. I bought Maya from you this summer, and fell in love. Very nicely shipped as well. :-)

As a bit of background on who we purchase from in Thailand, my first business dealings came with them in 1998, as a supplier for my Father's company, a regional broker of young plants since 1983 with brokering experience from 1972 starting with Ball Seed and then moving on to other International brokers, before starting his own.

The company is Chiang Mai Setcon, and is owned by a wonderful Thai woman, and her Japanese husband that actually runs it, Mr. Masaji Saito. I started Buried Treasures in 2002, offering bulbs and rhizomes from them as my sole supplier. While they have made their share of errors, as have I, the last thing on my mind is being sold a bill of goods. They are a major supplier that provides Hines Horticulture with 100% of their Curcuma crop, and more than 75% of their Plumeria Crop. My wife and I visit every couple of years, and stay on the farm, as well as visiting their suppliers that they outsource from.

I agree 100% on the Chatachuk surprise. I've picked up some stunning Adenium and Euphorbia hybrids, but won't buy a thing there that's not in bloom. The only exception has been some Amorphophallus bulbs that were huge. Those were for me, so it was safe. :-)


We did indeed commit to some of the golden foliage, though I'm not sold on it yet. I'm looking at some of mine now, and have my own version of golden foliage, and can't imagine a healthy one that won't look sickly, as do my current "golden" ones.

Chris

Geneva, FL(Zone 9b)

LOL--it is a bit disconcerting to see that color on a plumeria--that's for sure. However, the more I look at that picture, I find I am liking it. I would love to see a flower pic from this one, though the variegateds can be shy bloomers from what I have seen.

Brad

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.
BACK TO TOP