I have tentatively ID'd them. Please confirm or correct. Thanks!
First, Pine Warbler?
Barb
CLOSED: Help with Small Bird IDs
#2 is female house sparrow.
Pine Warbler
Blue Grosbeak female? not Goldfinch
Tennessee Warbler
#3 orange-crowned warbler.
I agree with pine warbler for #1.
Actually it's:
1. Pine Warbler
2. female House Sparrow
3. Palm Warbler
Throw in my 2 cents here
1 Pine Warbler
2 Female House Sparrow
3 Orange -crowned Warbler
With that chestnut crown I agree with Palm Warbler for # 3.
Ditto to
1. Pine Warbler
2. female House Sparrow
3. Palm Warbler
Resin
Thanks much everyone!
Barb
1. Yellow Bird
2. Brown Bird
3. Olive Yellow Bird.
LOL.
LOL, Mrs. Ed. Most times that seems to be the extent of my knowledge when it comes to these cute little guys. Unfortunately, I am still at the point where I need to have the book in hand when trying to ID them, yet it seems I have too few fingers to mark the pages of what I think one might be! I'm learning though.... I'm learning. :)
Barb
Same here! I take pictures first, then ask questions/look up in book later.
LOL!!!! That is usually my approach too Marna. Because when I look in the book first I do like I did this morning (grosbeak/purple finch) and get it wrong!!
One of the best identifiers for Palm Warblers is the tail wagging. I don't think any of the other warblers that winter in North Florida have that habit.
They look very similar, I agree. But for one, I think that it might be too late for grosbeaks in your area. The grosbeaks are also larger, more like cardinal size and have some yellow on the front.
Post a Reply to this Thread
More Bird Identification Threads
-
ID a Muskovy and something else?
started by FallSpring
last post by FallSpringApr 12, 20251Apr 12, 2025
