Dallas vs. Perry's Fire Opal

I have room for one more lily and I'm trying to choose between these two.
Unfortunately when I try to search the forum for comments/pictures I get every thread in which the word 'Dallas' appears!

Here's what I have to compare so far:

Fire Opal: 5-6" flowers, 3-4' spread, 7-10" leaves, full sun, bright pink award winner, good fragrance

Dallas: 4-5" flowers, 4-5' spread, 6-8" leaves, full-partial sun, medium pink, extremely fragrant


Do any of you have a favorite between these two?
I'm not attached to pink, but I do want a nice fragrant and hardy lily and I already have some white & yellow.

Thanks,
Teresa

I have Perrys Fire Opal and it is stunning. I dont know if its fragrant... I'll have to smell it.

Dont know about the other one.

charlotte

Thanks for the response, Charlotte.
I found the Dallas lily first (at Webbs) and since I needed to order something else from them I went with that one.
I'll post more info. once I see how it does!
Teresa