why can't i just root hibiscus in water?

Hibiscus are somewhat new to me....everything from cane begonias to hard wood cuttings just root easier and better for me in water this time of the year. Please tell if there is a good reason not to propagate in water. Mine are so sad looking with these hard freezes we have had and we are getting another freeze this week.....am tempted to go out and cut and cut (then put the mother plants in for protection) and put in water.
thanks

bettyG, I know some people do. But I prefer to dip in rooting powder as my success rate is very good that way. In fact, I just started rooting a bunch this morning. My mother plant of hib. Orange Key is in a big patio planter and I do not intend to protect it in any way at this time of year. Seems like you wouldn't need to do so either.

If you're interested, I will save you a rooted cutting, would love to trade you for one of those geraniums with the pink variegated flowers. That one is sweet!

Vossner, isn't that the strangest colors....pink with some pink red on it....I will be going back on Tuesday (they had a million of them) and I will be happy to trade you for a rooted cutting of hibiscus.....do you just want one?

Vossner, how long should my cuttings be if i stick them in water? How hard should I let the wood be?

One geranium that would be....I have to dmail you to have record....can't keep up with my wheelings and dealings....can't be a bad rep to start with???????????

This message was edited Feb 11, 2007 7:12 PM

B, I'm going to defer to someone that roots hibbies in water. I don't know. I haven't done well with that method. One geranium will do. thanks.

Betty,
You can root them in water, don't use real woody stems, try to get a cutting that is part green with a light gray color just starting. cut at an angle put in a glass of water, change every so often, if the water stays clear its just fine.Cuttings this way can take up to two months, depends on the cultivar and temps.Keep out of the sun and in a warm spot.

:-)

You are just the person I was waiting to hear from!!!! I don't care how long it takes and thanks for the advice on not getting too woody with the cuttings....Our weather has caused all my heating mats to be covered...thanks so much....I have a warm out !!!!!
thanks again, gail