CLOSED: Sparrow ID?

Lucketts, VA(Zone 7a)

I find sparrows difficult to tell apart (I'm new at this). Field guides do not show the differences as clearly as one might wish. Two candidtes I'm considering are White-Throated and White-Crrowned. Whem it bends down it looks a lot like a chipmunk. Here is a top view.

Thumbnail by greenthumb99
Lucketts, VA(Zone 7a)

Here is a side view

Thumbnail by greenthumb99
Marlton, NJ

Hi GT, The second photo is a Dark-eyed Junco- Right

White-throated Sparrow- Left

Sandusky, OH

Agree with pelletory on the 2nd picture. On your first photo I,m not sure...do you have another shot of the same bird?

Lucketts, VA(Zone 7a)

Hi Burd - I'm afraid that I don't have another photo that I can guarantee is the same bird. The two photos were taken several minutes apart. I thought that they were the same bird, but then if I were really knowledgable about birds I wouldn't be posting ID requests here. I thought that the "head shot" was distinctive, but none of my field guides compare top views of sparrows and many side depictions look alike to me. I'm really impressed by the level of observatrional skill and knowledge of a number of you out there.
Greenthumb99

Columbus, GA(Zone 8a)

No doubt the lower placed bird is definitely a Dark-eyed Junco.

Like Burd, I wish I had a little better pic of the bird on the left to examine, but that can't be helped. I looked hard at the bird, and like pellle, think it's a White-throated Sparrow. The throat certainly looks white to me. The next time you see it, look closely at the eyebrow and the throat, If it truly is a W-t Sparrow you will see a splash of yellow at the front of the eyebrow (supercillium). Look at my photo below to see the yellow area along with the white throat on my two birds.

Hack

This message was edited Feb 13, 2010 11:17 PM

Thumbnail by TheHackster
Sandusky, OH

Your first shot still could be Id-ed by another...hard to Id the top of the head without being absolutely correct. (for me anyways). I am curious..I hope it gets Id-ed also.

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.
BACK TO TOP