Trees, Shrubs and Conifers: Magnolia decision, 1 by greatswede

greatswede wrote:
In my back yard I have two different Magnolias. One is a Lily Magnolia (Magnolia liliiflora ‘Lil Ann) and the other a Saucer Magnolia (Magnolia soulangeana ‘Alexandria). These trees were planted about 8 months ago. This last summer saw temperatures around 116°F. These trees get western sun. The Lily Magnolia suffered from the heat and had a few burnt leaves. The Saucer Magnolia had a lot of burnt leaves and the rest were chewed on almost down to the branch. They are about 20 feet apart and both are in poor draining clay soil.

Should I give up on both of them and replace with something else? Or is there a spray for the Saucer Magnolia? I'm planting a fast growing shade tree next to the Lily Magnolia.

Below is a picture of the Saucer Magnolia.

What do you think is eating the Saucer Magnolia and not the Tulip?

This message was edited Oct 26, 2006 10:20 AM